do( ) Versus prepare( ) (Programming the Perl DBI)

start page | rating of books | rating of authors | reviews | copyrights

5.5. do( ) Versus prepare( )

As we mentioned in a previous section, the do( ) method supplied by the DBI makes executing non-SELECT statements much simpler than repeatedly preparing and executing statements. This is achieved by simply wrapping the prepare and execute stages into one composite method.

There is a drawback to doing this, however: performance. If you invoked do( ) repeatedly to insert a huge number of rows into a table, you could be preparing a statement handle many times more than is required, especially if the statement contained placeholder variables. For example, the following script inserts some rows into the megaliths table:

### Iterate through the various bits of data...
foreach $name ( qw( Stonehenge Avebury Castlerigg Sunhoney ) ) {
    ### ... and insert them into the table
    $dbh->do( "INSERT INTO megaliths ( name ) VALUES ( ? )", 
              undef, $name );
}

Internally, what happens is that for each row being inserted, a new statement handle is created, and the statement is prepared, executed, and finally destroyed. Therefore, this loop has four prepare calls, four executes, and four destroys. However, since we're using a bind value for each loop, the database will likely need to parse the statement only once and use that statement again from the Shared SQL Cache. Therefore, in essence, our program is "wasting" three prepares of that statement.

This is a rather inefficient process. In this case, it would be better to hand-prepare and re-execute the statement handle for each iteration of the loop. For example:

### Setup the statement for repeated execution
$sth = $dbh->prepare( "INSERT INTO megaliths ( name ) VALUES ( ? )" );

### Iterate through the various bits of data...
foreach $name ( qw( Stonehenge Avebury Castlerigg Sunhoney ) ) {
    ### ... and insert them into the table
    $sth->execute( $name );
}

This code prepares the statement only once and executes it four times, once per row to be inserted. This is slightly less convenient to write, but typically significantly faster to execute.

While we're on the subject of insertion speed, it's important to point out that there may be a faster way. Using a Perl script with the DBI is unlikely ever to be as fast for bulk loading of records as the database vendors' own specially optimized tools such as Oracle's SQL*Loader or Sybase's BCP. But don't lose heart; Perl is the ideal tool to create and manipulate the data files that these loaders use.


5.4. Binding Output Columns		5.6. Atomic and Batch Fetching